The MLB season is in full swing and that means it’s time for MLB The Show 23. Developer San Diego Studios’ latest release adds a lot more than just bells and whistles, but is it enough to warrant another yearly purchase of the franchise?
Read on to find out.
The MLB: The Show franchise has been around officially since 2006, but its video game roots go all the way back to 1998. The game of baseball itself has roots that go back quite a bit further, and not all of those roots belong solely to Major League Baseball. Prior to a guy named Jackie Robinson making his MLB debut on April 15th, 1947, there was an entire league of baseball that had some of the best ballplayers on the planet.

Guys like Satchel Paige, Rube Foster, and Hank Thompson, to name just a few, had more than enough talent to play at the MLB level but were relegated to the Negro Leagues based solely on their race. While MLB The Show 23 can’t change history, it can enlighten us on what the MLB missed out on due to segregated baseball leagues.
MLB The Show 23 Review – Negro League Storylines
The Negro League storylines took us on an adventure in history that few of us had completely known. Names like Jackie and Satchel are well known, but some of these other lesser known guys were just as talented. In the Negro Leagues Storyline mode, you’ll be introduced to eight players that had significant careers in the NLB, and can even unlock their playing cards to be used in Diamond Dynasty (DD) mode. These aren’t just moments to play, but include an in depth video presentation, in documentary format, that tells some incredible stories. Complete all of the moments successfully and you’ll unlock a new type of card for MLB The Show, the Buck O’Neil Captain card which boosts all of the NLB cards when in use in Diamond Dynasty.
MLB The Show 23 Review – Welcome the Captain
Ask any baseball fan from the last twenty years who the NY Yankee Captain is and most will mention Derek Jeter. The Hall of Fame shortstop had a long and storied career with the NY Yankees and still holds some all-time postseason records with 200 hits, 111 runs scored and 302 total bases. MLB The Show 23 brings him back into the league and along with him a new type of card we mentioned earlier: The Captain card.

Each Captain card, when certain requirements are met, bring with them attribute boosts for players that fall under their category. You can have one Pitching Captain and one Batting Captain, and you can see which players will get boosted when you are assembling your team in DD mode if that Captain is active. It’s a welcome addition to DD that is long overdue.
MLB The Show 23 Review – Bring Your Face to the Show
In MLB The Show 23 the long time favorite mode Road to the Show introduces something we have asked the developer to add for years. You can now use the MLB The Show companion app to scan your face and upload it into the game for your Created Player. You can’t carry your RTTS career from yearly release to yearly release anymore, and that’s disappointing, but at least now we can import our own faces into the game, giving us a whole new level of personalization.

MLB The Show 23 Review – DD Seasonal Content
Another new addition to MLB The Show 23‘s Diamond Dynasty mode is seasonal content. As you unlock cards either by opening packs or just playing the game, you’ll notice that each card has a new type associated with it. These cards will either be Core cards, which can be used all year, or will belong to a specific set of cards. The following image breaks it down for you.

MLB The Show 23 Review – Conclusion
Developer San Diego Studios has really taken MLB The Show 23 to the next level with all of the new content, as well as what they have coming throughout their full seasonal releases. Gameplay, graphics, and commentary are also enhanced and improved, so you can expect the best baseball simulator on the market. Period.
Well done SDS. Well done!
10
MLB The Show 23 review code provided by publisher and reviewed on a PS4 and PS5. For more information on scoring, please read What our review scores really mean.
























